Hamlet (Doran/Tennant) update 2021

 

New update 24 July 2021

Hamlet 2009 (Doran)

See update below. And happy birthday, Shakespeare!

 

• Director: Gregory Doran
• Seen by this director: The Winter’s Tale
• Based on play: by Shakespeare
• Cast: David Tennant, Patrick Stewart, Penny Downie, Oliver Ford Davies, Mariah Gale, Edward Bennett, Peter De Jersey, Sam Alexander, John Woodvine
• Personal “oh yeah him/her” reaction, i.e. have seen this actor in: note: we have seen many films with these actors since then and indeed, it was because of this film that we went looking for more roles played by David Tennant, thus discovering Doctor Who
• David Tennant – Deadwater Fell, Jessica Jones, Broadchurch, What We Did on Our Holiday, Doctor Who, The Politician’s Husband, Fright Night, The Decoy Bride, United, The Catherine Tate Show, St Trinians 2, Glorious 39, Secret Smile, Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Blackpool, Bright Young Things, Jude, Takin’ over the Asylum
• Patrick Stewart – The Hollow Crown, Hamlet (BBC), Star Trek, X-Men etc, Extras, Lady Jane, Dune, Excalibur, I Claudius, Antony and Cleopatra
• Penny Downie – Breathe, Downton Abbey, Invictus, The Girl in the Café
• Mariah Gale – Doctor Who, Broadchurch, The Hollow Crown, Measure for Measure
• Oliver Ford Davies – The Deep Blue Sea, Hamlet, Johnny English, Sense and Sensibility, Star Wars, Her Majesty Mrs. Brown, Mrs. Dalloway
• John Woodvine – Hamlet, The Other Boleyn Girl, An American Werewolf in London
• Seen: First time: a couple of years ago. Now: February 17, 2013 Now: 24 July 2021 

  One thing that noted scholar Harold Bloom is right about is that every actor does Hamlet differently. There could hardly be more difference between David Tennant’s performance and the stodgy Laurence Olivier, the earnest Mel Gibson, or the sullen, broody Ethan Hawke.

David Tennant’s Hamlet is frenzied, loony, goofy. And completely convincing. This scrawny Hamlet in jeans, tennis shoes (or barefoot) and ugly (but funny) orange T-shirt with skeleton ribs printed on it is manic and suffering. A brilliant achievement.

The time is now. The place is a hall of mirrors under surveillance cameras. Dramatic. Creepy. Atmospheric.

The rest of the cast? Mixed results. Polonius and Laertes (Davies and Bennett) do their jobs, nothing remarkable. Patrick Stewart, again playing Claudius, is a bit of a problem. He’s an excellent actor, of course, but I can’t quite figure out what he’s doing with Claudius.  His villainy is too sneaky, his remorse not convincing enough. But probably (I especially think so after watching the interview in the DVD special feature) Stewart is deliberately and rightly making Claudius a paradox, but it doesn’t quite succeed.

Horatio is a thankless role, maybe the most personality challenged figure in Shakespeare, but De Jersey does well. Horatio is likeable and supportive, and De Jersey makes him so.

Ophelia is well done by Mariah Gale.  A bit too wide-eyed for my tastes and more could have been done with the “O what a noble mind” soliloquy but her interpretation of mad Ophelia is very moving.

Penny Downie is the best Gertrude so far. It’s the closet scene that matters and this Gertrude is a bit too weepy and not angry enough, but she is at least angry and authoritative – she is Queen and a mother, after all – towards Hamlet at times, which is more than can be said of the other Gertrudes I’ve seen.

Not quite a perfect production then. But close enough. Very powerful, very gripping. 

9 ½ * of 10.

 

21 April 2018

Updated  

We’re watching it with our friends EG and EG with whom we have tickets to see Hamlet at the Globe in London in July. 

The first time Hal and I saw this film we said, ‘Oh this David Tennant is good, wonder what else he has done?’ Thus we discovered Doctor Who (we had heard of it but not seen much) and are now devoted Whovians.

 The four of us agree now that this is the best Hamlet film ever, even better than the brilliant but, with repeated viewing flawed Branagh version. My objections above have become milder. Downie’s Gertrude remains the best ever and David Tennant is - words fail me -  unsurpassable.

 This time I’m almost tempted to give it 10* of 10. But small objections so 

9.98* of 10

Update 24 July 2021 – I mostly agree with my previous reactions, but sad to say, I just don’t see Gale as Ophelia. Next week we’ll see Branagh’s version again. Can it retain its original status or will it glide down a little bit further on the list? Tennant and Lester are such superlative Hamlets…

This time I think 9 1/2* of 10.